The Distorting Impact of Capital Controls
Makram El-Shagi
German Economic Review,
No. 1,
2012
Abstract
This paper uses panel data to show that capital controls have a significant impact on international interest rate differentials. Various types of controls can be distinguished within the data. The analysis shows that the aforementioned effects of capital controls on interest rates are especially strong in the case of capital import controls on portfolio capital; the implementation of these controls has been suggested in the wake of the Asian Crisis to prevent further crises. The results presented herein contradict the hypothesis that capital controls can achieve a restructuring of the maturity of capital inflows without a distortion in international capital allocation.
Read article
Extreme Dependence with Asymmetric Thresholds: Evidence for the European Monetary Union
Stefan Eichler, R. Herrera
Journal of Banking and Finance,
No. 11,
2011
Abstract
Existing papers on extreme dependence use symmetrical thresholds to define simultaneous stock market booms or crashes such as the joint occurrence of the upper or lower one percent return quantile in both stock markets. We show that the probability of the joint occurrence of extreme stock returns may be higher for asymmetric thresholds than for symmetric thresholds. We propose a non-parametric measure of extreme dependence which allows capturing extreme events for different thresholds and can be used to compute different types of extreme dependence. We find that extreme dependence among the stock markets of ten initial EMU member countries, the United Kingdom, and the United States is largely asymmetrical in the pre-EMU period (1989–1998) and largely symmetrical in the EMU period (1999–2010). Our findings suggest that ignoring the possibility of asymmetric extreme dependence may lead to an underestimation of the probability of co-booms and co-crashes.
Read article
Stock Market Firm-Level Information and Real Economic Activity
Filippo di Mauro, Fabio Fornari, Dario Mannucci
ECB Working Paper,
No. 1366,
2011
Abstract
We provide evidence that changes in the equity price and volatility of individual firms (measures that approximate the definition of 'granular shock' given in Gabaix, 2010) are key to improve the predictability of aggregate business cycle fluctuations in a number of countries. Specifically, adding the return and the volatility of firm-level equity prices to aggregate financial information leads to a significant improvement in forecasting business cycle developments in four economic areas, at various horizons. Importantly, not only domestic firms but also foreign firms improve business cycle predictability for a given economic area. This is not immediately visible when one takes an unconditional standpoint (i.e. an average across the sample). However, conditioning on the business cycle position of the domestic economy, the relative importance of the two sets of firms - foreign and domestic - exhibits noticeable swings across time. Analogously, the sectoral classification of the firms that in a given month retain the highest predictive power for future IP changes also varies significantly over time as a function of the business cycle position of the domestic economy. Limited to the United States, predictive ability is found to be related to selected balance sheet items, suggesting that structural features differentiate the firms that can anticipate aggregate fluctuations from those that do not help to this aim. Beyond the purely forecasting application, this finding may enhance our understanding of the underlying origins of aggregate fluctuations. We also propose to use the cross sectional stock market information to macro-prudential aims through an economic Value at Risk.
Read article
The Importance of Estimation Uncertainty in a Multi-Rating Class Loan Portfolio
Henry Dannenberg
IWH Discussion Papers,
No. 11,
2011
Abstract
This article seeks to make an assessment of estimation uncertainty in a multi-rating class loan portfolio. Relationships are established between estimation uncertainty and parameters such as probability of default, intra- and inter-rating class correlation, degree of inhomogeneity, number of rating classes used, number of debtors and number of historical periods used for parameter estimations. In addition, by using an exemplary portfolio based on Moody’s ratings, it becomes clear that estimation uncertainty does indeed have an effect on interest rates.
Read article
What Might Central Banks Lose or Gain in Case of Euro Adoption – A GARCH-Analysis of Money Market Rates for Sweden, Denmark and the UK
Herbert S. Buscher, Hubert Gabrisch
IWH Discussion Papers,
No. 9,
2011
Abstract
This study deals with the question whether the central banks of Sweden, Denmark and the UK can really influence short-term money markets and thus, would lose this influence in case of Euro adoption. We use a GARCH-M-GED model with daily money market rates. The model reveals the co-movement between the Euribor and the shortterm interest rates in these three countries. A high degree of co-movement might be seen as an argument for a weak impact of the central bank on its money markets. But this argument might only hold for tranquil times. Our approach reveals, in addition, whether there is a specific reaction of the money markets in turbulent times. Our finding is that the policy of the European Central Bank (ECB) has indeed a significant impact on the three money market rates, and there is no specific benefit for these countries to stay outside the Euro area. However, the GARCH-M-GED model further reveals risk divergence and unstable volatilities of risk in the case of adverse monetary shocks to the economy for Sweden and Denmark, compared to the Euro area. We conclude that the danger of adverse monetary developments cannot be addressed by a common monetary
policy for these both countries, and this can be seen as an argument to stay outside the Euro area.
Read article
IWH-Indikatoren zur Kapitalmarktregulierung: Hinweise auf eine Renaissance der Kapitalverkehrskontrollen
Makram El-Shagi
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 6,
2011
Abstract
Mittels der hier erstmals vorgestellten IWH-Indikatoren zur Beschreibung der Regulierungsintensität internationaler Kapitalmärkte ist es möglich, Kapitalverkehrskontrollen künftig mit ökonometrischen Verfahren zu evaluieren. Der Datensatz deckt über 150 Länder und einen Zeitraum von bisher 13 Jahren (1997 bis 2009) ab. Er unterscheidet Kapitalverkehrskontrollen nicht nur nach ihrer Intensität, sondern auch nach der Richtung (Zufluss oder Abfluss) der regulierten Kapitalströme. So kann den unterschiedlichen Folgen von Kapitalmarktpolitik Rechnung getragen werden, je nachdem, ob sie durch Zuflusskontrollen dem Aufbau riskanter Außenpositionen entgegenwirken möchte, oder ob sie – wesentlich weiter verbreitet – auf eine Erhöhung des heimischen
Kapitalangebots abzielt. Die explizite Berücksichtigung von diskretionären Entscheidungsspielräumen gestattet es darüber hinaus, auch die institutionelle Ausgestaltung von Kapitalverkehrskontrollen in die empirische Analyse
einzubeziehen. Erste Auswertungen der Indikatoren zeigen in der Folge der Finanz- und Wirtschaftskrise eine weltweite Renaissance der Regulierung grenzüberschreitender Kapitalströme. Der Anteil regulierter Teilmärkte ist von 2007 bis 2009 global um ca. zehn Prozentpunkte angestiegen. Kapitalimporte und -exporte sind dabei in ähnlicher Form betroffen. Der Anstieg der Kontrollintensität geht nicht auf massive Eingriffe einzelner Staaten zurück, sondern ist
über alle betrachteten Ländergruppen hinweg zu beobachten. Teilweise, wie z. B. in den Transformationsökonomien des früheren Warschauer Paktes, wurden viele Jahre der Liberalisierungsanstrengungen in kurzer Zeit kompensiert. Diese Entwicklung ist insofern bedenklich, als dass sich theoretische Überlegungen bezüglich Kapitalverkehrskontrollen stark widersprechen und auch keine empirische Evidenz vorliegt, die eine solche Politik rechtfertigt.
Read article
Extreme Risks in Financial Markets and Monetary Policies of the Euro-candidates
Hubert Gabrisch, Lucjan T. Orlowski
Comparative Economic Studies,
No. 4,
2011
Abstract
This study investigates extreme tail risks in financial markets of the euro-candidate countries and their implications for monetary policies. Our empirical tests show the prevalence of extreme risks in the conditional volatility series of selected financial variables, that is, interbank rates, equity market indexes and exchange rates. We argue that excessive instability of key target and instrument variables should be mitigated by monetary policies. Central banks in these countries will be well-advised to use both standard and unorthodox (discretionary) tools of monetary policy while steering their economies out of the financial crisis and through the euro-convergence process.
Read article
Bericht über den IWH/INFER-Workshop on Applied Economics and Economic Policy
Katja Drechsel, Makram El-Shagi
Wirtschaft im Wandel,
No. 4,
2011
Abstract
Am 14. und 15. Februar 2011 fand am IWH erstmalig in Zusammenarbeit mit dem International Network for Economic Research (INFER) der Workshop „Applied Economics and Economic Policy“ statt. Wissenschaftlerinnen und Wissenschaftler europäischer Universitäten und internationaler Organisationen stellten einem breiten Publikum neueste Forschungsergebnisse zu aktuellen ökonomischen Fragen und Problemen vor. Der Workshop richtete sich neben einem wissenschaftlichen Publikum vor allem auch an Mitarbeiterinnen und Mitarbeiter internationaler Organisationen, wie beispielsweise der Europäischen Kommission und der Europäischen Zentralbank (EZB), sowie der verschiedenen Ministerien, wie z. B. der Wirtschaftsministerien. Ziel der Veranstaltung war es somit, nicht nur aktuelle Forschungsergebnisse vorzustellen, sondern auch mit Vertretern aus Wissenschaft und Praxis über aktuelle Wirtschaftspolitik und über das Spezialthema „The Empirics of Imbalances and Disequilibria“
zu diskutieren. Mit Lorenzo Bini Smaghi, Mitglied des Direktoriums der EZB, und Martin Hallet aus der Generaldirektion Wirtschaft und Finanzen der Europäischen Kommission konnten zwei hochrangige Vertreter aus den politischen Institutionen als Keynote-Speaker gewonnen werden.
Read article
Central and Eastern European Countries in the Global Financial Crisis: A Typical Twin Crisis?
Diemo Dietrich, Tobias Knedlik, Axel Lindner
Post-Communist Economies,
No. 4,
2011
Abstract
This paper shows that during the Great Recession, banking and currency crises occurred simultaneously in Central and Eastern Europe. Events, however, differed widely from what happened during the Asian crisis that usually serves as the model case for the concept of twin crises. We look at three elements that help explaining the nature of events in Central and Eastern Europe: the problem of currency mismatches, the relation between currency and banking crises, and the importance of multinational banks for financial stability. It is shown that theoretical considerations concerning internal capital markets of multinational banks help understand what happened on capital markets and in the financial sector of the region. We discuss opposing effects of multinational banking on financial stability and find that institutional differences are the key to understand differing effects of the global financial crisis. In particular, we argue that it matters if international activities are organized by subsidiaries or by cross-border financial services, how large the share of foreign currency-denominated credit is and whether the exchange rate is fixed or flexible. Based on these three criteria we give an explanation why the pattern of the crisis in the Baltic States differed markedly from that in Poland and the Czech Republic, the two largest countries of the region.
Read article
Exchange Rate Expectations and the Pricing of Chinese Cross-listed Stocks
Stefan Eichler
Journal of Banking and Finance,
No. 2,
2011
Abstract
I show that the price discounts of Chinese cross-listed stocks (American Depositary Receipts (ADRs) and H-shares) to their underlying A-shares indicate the expected yuan/US dollar exchange rate. The forecasting models reveal that ADR and H-share discounts predict exchange rate changes more accurately than the random walk and forward exchange rates, particularly at long forecast horizons. Using panel estimations, I find that ADR and H-share investors form their exchange rate expectations according to standard exchange rate theories such as the Harrod–Balassa–Samuelson effect, the risk of competitive devaluations, relative purchasing power parity, uncovered interest rate parity, and the risk of currency crisis.
Read article
